mentalism

JAMES PHELAN: SHOWMAN

☆☆☆☆

When assessing Fringe shows, it’s not always fair to judge the quality of the venue, with such a variety of possibilities and with performers not always having perfect control over which they are allocated to. However, it is impossible to deny the powerful effect of setting, for good or ill, on any performance experience. Entering James Phelan’s tent for Showman, the most obvious first impression is that not only does he have a beautiful venue, but his set design is gorgeously put together to make the absolute most of it. Phelan lets his audience in early to enjoy the ambiance and pre-show live music, a relaxing contrast to the usual Fringe rush to get seated as quickly as possible. Once he takes to the stage, that calming trend continues.

Phelan demonstrates his mentalist abilities in a variety of ways, but his specialty here is hypnotism, and this is where he spends the majority of the show—perhaps more than usual at the reviewed show. The entire audience might get involved at first, in a series of activities that prove both interesting and relaxing, before Phelan chooses those who stand out to join him for a deeper hypnotic experience. Phelan manages to demonstrate an astonishing range of hypnotic and mentalist effects, in a way that gets many un-hypnotized members of the audience involved from their seats.

If Phelan is known for any one thing as much as hypnotism, it’s his excellence in dealing with the audience, as a collective but most especially as individuals. Phelan manages to make friends with a solid proportion of them at the reviewed show. His carefully casual attitude makes those who join him onstage feel welcome, without ever doubting that he is the one in control. He is such a welcoming host that at the reviewed show one of his participants took off her shoes to allow her to more easily accomplish her tasks, even leaning on Phelan to do so—far from a common occurrence at a magic show, or even a hypnotism show. While this behavior is not encouraged, the fact that it happened exemplifies the audience’s immediate trust in and affection for Phelan as soon as they meet him.

The theme of Showman might be the contrast between fragility and permanence, but, even with his mentalist powers, Phelan may not have been able to predict just how well the reviewed show would emphasize this. Whether his participants were unexpectedly leaning on him to remove their shoes or generally struggling with their role in the show, Phelan experienced a remarkable range of ways that audience participants can inadvertently attempt to derail a magic show, through no fault of his own. The audience was left with no doubt that he uses genuine participants without relying on stooges. What began as a magic show temporarily transitioned into a masterclass in participant management, as Phelan masterfully ensured that he got what he needed from his audience with the calm demeanor of a gracefully gliding swan that was undoubtedly paddling beneath the surface with increasing urgency. This became, as well, an active demonstration of Phelan’s ability to transform the fragile relationship between audience participants and his show into a permanent reminder of the power and at times sheer force of will that makes a true Showman. The strength of Phelan’s theme was clearly developed through the ordinary course of his show as well, he certainly didn’t “need” the audience’s help, but the events of the reviewed show ended up handing him an unexpected way to underline his point.

Phelan will guarantee that his audience gets the full experience of Showman, of that they can be certain. At the reviewed show he risked the notorious wrath of his venue management by running well over his allocated time to ensure that he could complete his show in spite of participant-related delays. This commitment to his audience’s experience is undoubtedly at least one of the reasons why Phelan is regularly selling out this Fringe. Prospective audiences had better act fast if they want to catch him in his beautiful tent.

ANDREW MCKINLAY: CLASSIFIED

☆☆

In a colorful central venue, Andrew McKinlay can be found performing his mentalist show Classified… or at least, that’s his cover for recruiting for the mysterious Bureau, one audience at a time. McKinlay takes his audiences through a series of tests to judge their suitability to join up. While the show is not not flawless and McKinlay seems to struggle at times to connect with his audience, it’s an entertaining time.

McKinlay has made an effort to theme his effects for a recruitment drive, and by and large he’s done a good job. Perhaps, in this case, slightly too good of a job, as his reveals may come to feel a bit same-y. To a skeptic this is arguably a feature of magic in general, but many Fringe magicians add in enough creativity and variety of effects to keep their shows interesting. The effects employed are all mentalist in nature, so perhaps particularly suited to fans of that genre of magic.

With a relatively small venue and recruitment theme, McKinlay is able to include pretty much the entire audience in his act at the reviewed show. Results are complimentary, with McKinlay ensuring that everyone passes the tests and is judged suitable for The Bureau. McKinlay is a friendly presence, and makes participation feel more like the most chill job interview ever than like joining a magician onstage.

McKinlay struggles slightly with timing and connection with the audience throughout the show. He has a tendency to draw out the setup, slowly showing the audience nearly all the cards or pages in a notebook where it might feel slicker to just show a few as a representative sample. The connection with the audience may be more a problem with the audience at the reviewed show, which was slightly combative, than with McKinlay himself. After the show McKinlay could be seen chatting to tables of strangers at his venue with more charm and charisma than he displayed during the show. While it’s unfortunate that McKinlay wasn’t able to recover this show’s audience, he is clearly able to win over others.

The reviewed show of Classified may have been a mixed experience, but McKinlay is clearly a competent performer and his concept for the show has an interesting potential. Mentalism enthusiasts, and those who would like to join The Bureau, may enjoy it.

MAX DAVIDSON: STRANGERS

☆☆☆

Max Davidson doesn’t even need to be onstage to get his audience to do what he wants. His new Fringe show Strangers opens with instructions for his first participant, who is whoever is first to self-select from the audience, before Davidson even introduces himself. At the reviewed show the potential awkward silence had no time to develop before someone leapt to the stage. Davidson is clearly attracting an enthusiastic audience, and his trust in them is both heartwarming and justified.

Davidson’s theme for his magic is memory. A popular genre of tricks, most magic fans will have seen a magician perform one of two of the effects that he uses, but rarely all of them at once. Notably, during one routine Davidson openly and lightheartedly admits that his goal is to gaslight his participant. Many, perhaps most, magicians will attempt to gaslight some or all of their audience during their shows, the best so successfully that, aside from the tacit consent of purchasing a ticket for a magic show, it passes unnoticed by the audience. Few have the honesty and talent to admit to it ahead of time and still pull it off.

The vast majority of the tricks used may be familiar to magic fans, but Davidson puts them together in routines that, by virtue of their creative combinations, feel fresh and interesting. A highlight sees him read a piece of information from a random participant’s mind that hasn’t been written down or mentioned in any way ahead of time, for a particularly impressive reveal. While at the reviewed show not everything goes perfectly to plan, Davidson pivots excellently to keep the energy up and the magic flowing.

Despite admitting to attempted gaslighting, Davidson comes across as warm and welcoming to those who participate in his magic—the honesty is perhaps beneficial here. Davidson pulls from volunteers for his more involved participation moments, and at the reviewed show there is no shortage. The appreciation he expresses to each participant who joins him leaves the rest of the audience increasingly happy to take a turn onstage as the show goes on.

Davidson’s premise is that the audience might arrive Strangers to him, but by the time they leave he will know everything he needs to to read their minds. By the time they see his impressive finale, the audience may very well agree. His audiences will be pleased to no longer consider Davidson a stranger.

THE TELEPATH AND THE CONJUROR

☆☆☆

The Oberons, Marc and Emily, make for a very sweet double act. Their introduction in The Telepath and the Conjuror is a retelling of their meet-cute as cruise ship performers. The type of magic performed and their style of performance feels classily vintage, and the largely well executed reveals make for a successful magic show.

The Oberons’ areas of expertise are divided as per their show title, with Marc handing the conjuring and Emily the telepathy. Prior to their meeting, Emily evidently worked as a singer, and while musical analysis is outside the scope of this publication, she does sing at several points in this show. At times she essentially performs a live soundtrack to Marc’s conjuring act, which is a really lovely combination of their skills. A highlight in this is the bottle appearing routine that they perform together, with Emily singing her appreciation and approval of Marc’s provision of her favorite beverage. Much of the magic performed feels old fashioned, with props like floating wands and metal circles, and mentalism performed blindfolded with items from the audience. This is not necessarily a bad thing, the material performed suits the style of the performance.

Several audience participants are used in the act, often chosen from volunteers. Where random participants are selected, the Oberons ensure they give them easier tasks. They have a plentiful supply of volunteers to choose from, with a welcoming stage presence that makes all feel comfortable joining in. At the reviewed performance they had several younger participants, and one in particular accentuated the reveal of the trick she was involved in, with her involuntary gasp of amazement ensuring that the rest of the audience knew that the trick had been successful.

The Telepath and the Conjuror has its niche in those who appreciate the classics of magic, whether as a newcomer to the art form or as a fan looking to be reminded of the roots of the genre. The Oberons have a pleasantly romantic stage chemistry—a good sign for an offstage couple—and are lovely to watch. As both a throwback to a classier era of magic than is often seen at the Fringe, and as a general reminder that love is real, The Telepath and the Conjuror is an excellent choice.

THE REMARKABLE BEN HART

☆☆☆☆☆

The Fringe’s favorite oddity Ben Hart is back, with a show title that sounds egotistical even by magic standards, The Remarkable Ben Hart. At the reviewed show the wind may have threatened to blow down his circus tent, but Edinburgh was not deterred. Not a seat was left empty on that windy Monday evening. The enthusiasm was justified, as was Hart’s ego, as Hart turned out one of his signature perfect and inventive performances.

The way that Hart uses magic is creative in both emphasizing the visual beauty of his effects and in making them more magically impressive. The assembly of his cutlery effect in particular addresses potential moments when skepticism might creep in, making the reveal all the more impressive. His mentalist routine is notable as well. Hart primarily performs physical magic, where, by its nature, the audience can see the magic happening.  Hart’s usual performance style takes advantage of that innate feature to create stylish visuals on his stage. With mentalism that innate materiality is not necessarily there, but Hart’s staging and showmanship make the effect blend seamlessly in to the distinct iconography of Hart brand, creating visual appeal to magic that is performed in the mind.

Aside from creative, visually beautiful magic, Hart loves a theme, and The Remarkable Ben Hart does not disappoint. The theme is not in fact just that he’s uniquely remarkable, although the audience may find themselves agreeing with that sentiment as well by the end of the show. While it would be a shame to make available from the start what Hart works so hard to build up over the course of an hour, future audiences can be reassured that this renowned storyteller has not given up on that element of his craft.

Like all performers, and especially magicians, Hart has to deal with members of the public in his show. Hart expertly choreographs his audience participants to ensure that they can perform their roles while also giving the whole of the audience a view of the magic, a notable challenge for a magician performing in the round. As the reviewed show took place during stormy weather, Hart also had to contend with Mother Nature herself heckling him, with howling winds that threatened to bring down his tent. Hart’s response to the wind revealed the practiced professionalism of a performer who regularly works in tents in Edinburgh—this is undoubtedly not the first time he has had to deal with that particular interruption.

The Remarkable Ben Hart is well worth braving the Edinburgh weather. Hart is constantly innovating in the performance of his craft, making him an exciting performer to return to year after year. Rain, shine, or hurricane, Hart’s tent is the place to be.

JAMES PHELAN: THE MAN WHO WAS MAGIC

☆☆☆☆

In the hierarchy of Fringe venues, James Phelan has undoubtedly earned the use of one of the best this year, with The Man Who Was Magic finding its home in the beautiful McEwan Hall. Phelan honors the venue with an equally beautiful magic show that makes great use of the space. With a well-balanced mix of hypnotic effects, mind reading, and magic, Phelan’s show is as ever the crowd pleaser, with a real heart to back up the tricks.

One of Phelan’s notable strengths as a performer is in his crowd work, and this was readily apparent at the reviewed show. With his quick wit and charm Phelan has an easy chemistry with everyone who he invites to get involved in the show. Participants are made to feel comfortable, and as Phelan keeps all the hard work for himself participation feels particularly unthreatening. McEwan Hall is a big room, but like every good host Phelan turns the space into a welcoming home.

The hypnotism and magic performed are all done with exceptional skill. At the reviewed performance there were a few noticeable teething issues—nothing out of the ordinary for the second day of the Fringe—but if there were any genuine problems with the tricks performed, Phelan played them off so well that the audience was left unsure if these were planned “mistakes” to set up the reveal, which is surely the truest tell of magical excellence. A crowd-pleasing highlight is Phelan’s ring trick, with a reveal that neatly ties in to the show’s theme of making the important things permanent, which in this case took the form of a permanent testament to the impermanent moment of the reveal.

That theme of creating permanence may initially seem at odds with the medium of live performance, a necessarily impermanent art. Phelan navigates this in part with the obvious, the gifting of souvenirs to his various participants, and in part in autobiographical storytelling and general inspiration. In a way his slick handling of early-Fringe issues contributed to the theme as well, with the temporary technological problems becoming surpassed by the permanent impression of controlled professionalism that he leaves on the audience. Phelan even refreshes a form of final reveal that in other hands feels overused, breathing new life into this classic magical ending by imbuing it with new meaning.

Phelan, the Man Who Was Magic himself, is certainly one to see this year for anyone in need of an uplifting hour, which would probably be just about everyone this year. His show is one of those impermanent things that is worth being made permanent, whether in reviews, in the futures of those who he takes the time to inspire, or even just in the memories of everyone in his audiences.

JOSH STALEY: FOOL ME ONCE

☆☆☆☆

If the complicated role of a magician could be distilled to just one core job, it would definitely be to fool their audience. The stated premise of Josh Staley’s Fool Me Once is thus in a way the first time of the evening that he fulfills his core duties—he does, in the end, fool his audience more than once. It’s a simple premise and Staley uses it effectively.

Staley uses both sleight of hand magic and mentalism to fool the audience. An early highlight is his coin routine. In fact, at the reviewed show, as he completed this routine a member of the audience audibly whispered to her friends, “I love the coins”, a sentiment that, at that point, was surely shared by everyone else watching, and which Staley confirmed that he shared as well. Staley also read several minds, both from written prompts and from words that existed solely in the minds of his audience members.

Audience participation in Fool Me Once is used thoughtfully and effectively. Several participants are able to get involved from their seats, including for an exciting finale to the above-mentioned beloved coin routine that sees a magical element happen in the hands of an audience member. When audience participants get more involved, whether in coming onstage to have a turn at presenting a reveal or even just completing an impressive shuffle, Staley celebrates their achievements and makes sure they get applause for their contribution to his show.

It’s not always a good sign when the magician has to deal with significant numbers of audience member mistakes and interruptions, but at the reviewed show Staley dealt with several such matters with exemplary professionalism. An early example saw a participant helping Staley with a card trick misunderstand his instructions to hide her chosen card in the deck, instead hiding it under his box of props. On discovering this miscommunication Staley recovered the effect with a joke and a well performed bit of sleight of hand. Staley also had to contend with a gaggle of chatty youngsters, and managed to shut down their side conversations with quick good humor.

The reviewed show of Fool Me Once was nearly if not entirely sold out, on a Saturday evening in Adelaide at a prime time slot with plenty of competition. It’s no surprise, it’s a well staged show and Staley is a charming performer. If any tickets remain for the rest of his Fringe run future audiences will surely have to hurry to nab them.

2 RUBY KNOCKERS, 1 JADED DICK

☆☆☆

Of the professions in which mentalist powers would be most useful in daily life, private detective must be high on the list. The character Dirk Darrow brings that fantasy to life in 2 Ruby Knockers, 1 Jaded Dick. The show had the feel of a comedic one man play with magical elements, certainly a welcome creative angle on the magic scene. It may not be flawless, but it’s undoubtedly a good time.

2 Ruby Knockers is framed as an investigation by Darrow into a series of crimes committed in his vicinity. The overlap in skill set required in creating an effective mystery and performing magic is not insignificant, there’s an element of misdirection required in both. The mystery of 2 Ruby Knockers is both effective and a lot of fun, full of plot twists and surprises. In that respect it’s a fitting tribute to a beloved genre and demonstrative of a level of magic-adjacent skill.

Throughout the investigation, Darrow uses both plenty of intentionally bad jokes and various magical techniques to advance the plot. The magic may seem fairly basic to regular magic show attendees, but it’s performed effectively and deployed sensibly throughout the narrative. As the audience filters in, they see cards on several of the seats to fill in with personal information for Darrow to later magically discover. This segment fits well with the plot and proves entertaining for the audience. A storytelling sequence using a deck of cards is a particular highlight. If some of the bits seem a little forced, it’s easy to forgive—there’s not a whole lot of variety in a standard deck—and it’s a creative use of a classic prop.

As in most magic shows, Darrow frequently utilizes his audience’s assistance. Most of the participation is relaxed, and done without even requiring the participant to go onstage. The occasional audience member is called on to participate a little more significantly in the show, but Darrow chooses well and guides them effectively in fulfilling their roles as he requires them. However, he does occasionally seem to falter when his audience does something unexpected, particularly noticeable at the reviewed show when he receives a funny heckle, although also evident in a couple other instances. Heckling is an often unfortunate aspect of live performance, but in the realm of heckling a funny heckle is the best option. Darrow may benefit from working on reacting more gracefully to interruptions and irregularities—unfortunately he’s in a profession where such a skill is necessary.

2 Ruby Knockers, 1 Jaded Dick appeals primarily as a comedy for those who adore puns. While there may be other performers at this year’s festival who perform magic more slickly and with more creativity in the crafting of their effects, 2 Ruby Knockers has value as a magic show in demonstrating a different type of creativity in presentation. The audience at the reviewed show certainly loved Darrow. His humor and overall performance style is pretty specific, and the right audience seems to have found him.

CHRISTIAN LAVEY: ENCHANTING MINDS – A NIGHT OF MAGIC AND MINDREADING

☆☆☆

Hailing all the way from Luxembourg, Christian Lavey presents his Adelaide Fringe debut Enchanting Minds—A Night of Magic and Mindreading in a pleasantly cool room conveniently in the center of town. As far as show structure goes, Lavey keeps it simple and straightforward. With his engaging stage presence and well performed mentalism, it is certainly an entertaining evening.

The magic that Lavey presents is a series of his favorite tricks, organized neatly to provide an escalating degree of impressive reveals. As a non-native speaker of English, one trick involving a reveal of reciting non-linear lists of numbers stands out as especially well performed. The reveal itself is of course innately impressive, but as any language learner will know, listing random numbers in a non-native language is a particularly difficult skill to master. It is commendable that Lavey not only chose to include this trick in his first Adelaide fringe show, but also that at the reviewed show he presented the reveal without a hitch.

The success of this trick was not a unique feature, Lavey’s magic is well performed throughout. His sock card trick was a highlight, with a fun reveal that neatly led in to the next effect in a slick transition. The venue is relatively intimate and Lavey gets the majority of the audience involved in his show. The majority of the participation is completed while staying seated, saving time to pack in more magic and keeping the level of participation required fairly relaxed. Lavey is welcoming to everyone who gets involved in his show, whether from their seats or with him on stage.

Lavey is evidentially a skilled performer, the smooth delivery of both his routines and patter indicate a wealth of experience. However, as with every magic show, the audience participants are still a wildcard. At the reviewed show one in particular adds flair to the segment she participates in—a classic “dangerous item” routine. She eagerly inspected the items that Lavey uses, and, with equal eagerness, selected and deployed them, risking harming Lavey with each choice, all with zero hesitation. This was not due to indifference to Lavey’s potential harm, but, she explained, due to her trust that he knew what he was doing. Her contribution to the act made for an unusually wholesome take on this classic of magic.

Lavey successfully enchants the minds of the audience of Enchanting Minds. Perhaps the best measure of the success of a show is how the audience gossips amongst itself once they are out of earshot of the performer, and following the reviewed performance of Enchanting Minds audience members could be heard extremely pleased to have experienced such a well performed show to kickstart their evening. Despite the central location, the venue is tucked away a bit from the gardens that the Fringe revolves around, giving Enchanting Minds the feel of a hidden gem of a show. With its great tricks and Lavey’s skilled performance, it can only be a success.

REUBEN MORELAND: ABRACADABRA, B*TCH!

☆☆☆☆

It’s a satisfying moment in a book or movie when one of the characters says the title of the work in conversation. Audiences at magic shows don’t often get that particular moment of minor joy. Reuben Moreland, however, does things differently, leaping to the stage yelling, “Abracadabra, B*tch!” to kick off his highly energetic show. It’s a delightfully and consistently silly show, and a genuine pleasure to watch.

The magic that Moreland performs is remarkably well styled to his stage presence. If it could be said that there is a theme or story to the show, it’s relatively minimal—a running joke is used as a structure around which Moreland organizes the bulk of the content. This suits the type of comedy magic that he performs. It’s the personalization of the magic that is most impressive. Even the most ardent magic fan will take a moment to discern the bones of a familiar trick disguised so completely by the trappings of his performance.

Moreland set the tone early, with a series of magic tricks and jokes illustrating a hopefully completely imaginary disaster of a first date. This gets all the stereotypical props and classic self-deprecating magician humor out of the way early for those who turned up to see a magic show expecting such things. Later highlights include a signed card trick, featuring a reveal that Moreland had set up pretty much from the start of the show. This interweaving of effects and reveals is in itself a highlight. The attention to detail and exact timing pays off in the audience experience.

Like many magic shows, Abracadabra, B*tch! relies heavily on audience participation. Moreland does occasionally ask a bit more of his participants than most. At the reviewed show there was one significant participant who was chosen by Moreland apparently at random. Luckily Moreland appears to have mastered the most crucial mentalist trick any magician must learn: how to intuit, from the stage, which member of the audience will have fun playing along with his act. While Moreland’s choice to pick this particular participant at random was the right decision for his narrative, at other moments he opened the stage to volunteers, many of whom were eager to join in the fun.

At one point in the show, Moreland jokingly questions, “What kind of a person would actually buy a ticket to see a show called “Abracadabra, B*tch!”? The answer is, exactly the kind of person who would most enjoy the show. It’s very well named to let potential audiences know what they’re getting themselves in for when they purchase their ticket. For those to whom the title appeals, the silliness will be a delight.