☆☆☆☆

When assessing Fringe shows, it’s not always fair to judge the quality of the venue, with such a variety of possibilities and with performers not always having perfect control over which they are allocated to. However, it is impossible to deny the powerful effect of setting, for good or ill, on any performance experience. Entering James Phelan’s tent for Showman, the most obvious first impression is that not only does he have a beautiful venue, but his set design is gorgeously put together to make the absolute most of it. Phelan lets his audience in early to enjoy the ambiance and pre-show live music, a relaxing contrast to the usual Fringe rush to get seated as quickly as possible. Once he takes to the stage, that calming trend continues.

Phelan demonstrates his mentalist abilities in a variety of ways, but his specialty here is hypnotism, and this is where he spends the majority of the show—perhaps more than usual at the reviewed show. The entire audience might get involved at first, in a series of activities that prove both interesting and relaxing, before Phelan chooses those who stand out to join him for a deeper hypnotic experience. Phelan manages to demonstrate an astonishing range of hypnotic and mentalist effects, in a way that gets many un-hypnotized members of the audience involved from their seats.

If Phelan is known for any one thing as much as hypnotism, it’s his excellence in dealing with the audience, as a collective but most especially as individuals. Phelan manages to make friends with a solid proportion of them at the reviewed show. His carefully casual attitude makes those who join him onstage feel welcome, without ever doubting that he is the one in control. He is such a welcoming host that at the reviewed show one of his participants took off her shoes to allow her to more easily accomplish her tasks, even leaning on Phelan to do so—far from a common occurrence at a magic show, or even a hypnotism show. While this behavior is not encouraged, the fact that it happened exemplifies the audience’s immediate trust in and affection for Phelan as soon as they meet him.

The theme of Showman might be the contrast between fragility and permanence, but, even with his mentalist powers, Phelan may not have been able to predict just how well the reviewed show would emphasize this. Whether his participants were unexpectedly leaning on him to remove their shoes or generally struggling with their role in the show, Phelan experienced a remarkable range of ways that audience participants can inadvertently attempt to derail a magic show, through no fault of his own. The audience was left with no doubt that he uses genuine participants without relying on stooges. What began as a magic show temporarily transitioned into a masterclass in participant management, as Phelan masterfully ensured that he got what he needed from his audience with the calm demeanor of a gracefully gliding swan that was undoubtedly paddling beneath the surface with increasing urgency. This became, as well, an active demonstration of Phelan’s ability to transform the fragile relationship between audience participants and his show into a permanent reminder of the power and at times sheer force of will that makes a true Showman. The strength of Phelan’s theme was clearly developed through the ordinary course of his show as well, he certainly didn’t “need” the audience’s help, but the events of the reviewed show ended up handing him an unexpected way to underline his point.

Phelan will guarantee that his audience gets the full experience of Showman, of that they can be certain. At the reviewed show he risked the notorious wrath of his venue management by running well over his allocated time to ensure that he could complete his show in spite of participant-related delays. This commitment to his audience’s experience is undoubtedly at least one of the reasons why Phelan is regularly selling out this Fringe. Prospective audiences had better act fast if they want to catch him in his beautiful tent.